If someone is considering offering public service, it is certainly fair to consider why it is that one would want to serve. And, in fact, those are the kinds of topics the would-be civic leaders most want to discuss. Generally, they have some frustration (or occasionally even anger) regarding this topic or another. “Teachers are under appreciated!” says one. “Schools are bloated with tax dollars!” says another. And, others still are simply responding to a desire to give back referring to a family member or mentor that inspired them to commit. “Mom worked tirelessly for the PTA and now that I have kids, it seems like the right thing to do.” All the answers are right from the perspective of the giver; and, we should be eager to support the instinct to service.
But to me, there is a more important question. Does one have the temperament to sustain peer criticism (or even to be a part of the minority caucus)? In my experience, the critique is most harsh closest to home. Indeed, familiarity breeds contempt. Neighborhood association officers have folks showing up on their doorsteps demanding intervention in the on-going feud over the trashcan placement. Next in line, School Board members feel the heat of tight budgets and are ascribed all sort of aspersions often based in frustration not fact. Next in line are local government officials. We see these fine people at softball games and the town parade and are willing to “remind” them of our street care need and tax burden. Finally, in order are State and National representatives – they have staff to shield but must come back from DC at least to run for reelection.
Accountability may not be as important as ideology; but if one wants to serve, isn’t it a big part of the equation.
But to me, there is a more important question. Does one have the temperament to sustain peer criticism (or even to be a part of the minority caucus)? In my experience, the critique is most harsh closest to home. Indeed, familiarity breeds contempt. Neighborhood association officers have folks showing up on their doorsteps demanding intervention in the on-going feud over the trashcan placement. Next in line, School Board members feel the heat of tight budgets and are ascribed all sort of aspersions often based in frustration not fact. Next in line are local government officials. We see these fine people at softball games and the town parade and are willing to “remind” them of our street care need and tax burden. Finally, in order are State and National representatives – they have staff to shield but must come back from DC at least to run for reelection.
Accountability may not be as important as ideology; but if one wants to serve, isn’t it a big part of the equation.
This column was published on Tuesday, October 11, 2011 in the Current in Carmel, Current in Westfield,
Current in Fishers , and Current in Noblesville - http: //youarecurrent.com/